Message Boards

The Backfire Effect

I am really upset that President Trump is backing out of the Paris Accord. I believe global warming is a very current, very important issue that should be discussed. Everyone has different opinions, however, which I respect. Some people might not think the Paris Accord is as important as I think it is. On Friday, I had a discussion with one of those people. A person in my class said his/her opinion was that global warming was not real, was not happening, and didn't need to be addressed. This person then told me the Paris Accord wasn't important either. A bell went off in my head, saying: "This person has the stupidest opinion and they're WRONG." I told him/her "Your opinion is your opinion is your opinion, and my opinion is my opinion." The conversation ended at that, and I felt guilty for thinking that the person's opinion was stupid, because like I said, I respect other people's opinions. I did some research, and found something called the "backfire effect." This is when someone is provided with evidence that goes against their beliefs, but they reject the evidence and continue to believe. There is a lot of evidence of climate change, but you can choose to believe it or not. I still think global warming is an important issue, and the person in my class still thinks it is not. I've found the backfire effect in a few more instances since my interaction on Friday, and realize how peculiar it is, and how strong people's core beliefs can be. I encourage everyone to realize the backfire effect. It's hard to change, because it's how your brain is made. Even though we are all hard-wired with the backfire effect, it opened my mind and I see different opinions in a new light. 

You need to be a member of NMG Members to add comments!

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I totally agree. My science book is awful, its all like "global warming doesn't exist" "pollution is totally not happening and totally not killing tons of innocent sea turtles and animals around the world" I am so upset!!
  • You are absolutely right. I was very angry when trump backed out of the Paris accord. That was the first step to recovery from global warming worldwide!I have heard of the backfire effect but have always been confused by it!
  • Honestly I don't think that global warming is a opinion. It's a fact.
    • ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    • ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    • ^^^^^^^^^^
    • ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    • ^^^
    • Exactly! It's like saying "Abraham Lincoln is dead" is an opinion!
      • ^^^^^^
This reply was deleted.

Sister to Sister Message Board

Mod S2S Mentor

Sister to Sister: What Do YOU Want to Hear About?

Hi all! As you may already know, my fellow Sister to Sister mentors and I do our best to respond to any and all questions you submit through this form (as mentioned on the main S2S page, questions can be about anything from school to friendship to body image to peer pressure... or anything else), with the best advice we can come up with; you can also choose to be anonymous in the response, if you like. In addition to this, we also write blog posts/articles; you'll typically see a new one…

Read more…
15 Replies · Reply by Sarah 4 hours ago
Mod S2S Mentor

Dishonest Friend

So I have this friend and when we first met she was really nice and we connected, we became best friends like right away. 3 months later she moved but not far just 10 minutes away (she used to live 1 block away) so at first we were still really close but then she started lying about everything. I found out she lied about stuff she told me when she first met. She said she had no friends then a couple weeks ago she started school and she was saying how much fun she has had with all her friends.…

Read more…
2 Replies · Reply by Julia Dec 6
Mod S2S Mentor

Helping a Friend

"I have this friend who doesn't think she's pretty, and she also thinks she's fat. Neither of these are true, and I've told her so, but she doesn't believe me. Advice?" - Anonymous I can definitely relate to this issue, since one of my friends thinks the same thing. I think you're doing the right thing by telling your friend that these negative things aren't true. When I'm with my friend, I tell her the same thing, no matter how many times she talks negatively about herself. In addition to…

Read more…
2 Replies · Reply by Mila Dec 4

Ask A Girl: Need advice? Give great advice? We help each other! Ask your questions or answer any of the questions already here. Your post will appear in a day or two, so check back often. We've had many girls ask if their questions can be anonymous, and that is not possible on this website. We want you to know that girls in NMG can trust each other, even with embarrassing questions. And if you want to, you can change your user name to a "not real" name that will then also be used in the magazine if your Ask A Girl question is published.

Letters To Luna: I'm Luna, the spirit of New Moon. Write a letter to me with your opinions and suggestions about the magazine and website. I love to read all your notes! Because I get so many letters, I can't reply online. But a select few letters get published in each issue!

Body & Feelings: Body image, mood swings, puberty, your first period, and so much more! The information girls need!

Check It Out: Share your rants and raves about books, magazines, movies, products, music, ads, tv, internet and more. Love it? Hate it? Let us know!

For The Curious: How does stuff in our world happen? Post and ask about experiments, tech, coding, math,  science, engineering, and more!  It's all about the weird, wonderful, and wacky! Be curious and be surprised.

Go Girls & Women Change the World: Amazing girls and women make the world a better place every day. Tell us about who you admire - now and from the past.  These don't have to be people who are already famous!

How Aggravating & Howl at the Moon: Tell us when you see something that's unfair to girls and women -you can vent about it here! And, Howl out your accomplishments and the things that make you proud as a person and a girl!

Love Remembers: Whether it's losing a beloved pet or a cherished person, loss is painful and can be difficult to cope with. But talking about our loved ones and keeping their memories alive can help. Share your beautiful memories here.

Random Stuff: Want a place to be silly, start message board games, or talk about stuff that doesn't fit into the other categories? Then check out this message board!

Role Play: Do you like role playing games? RPG’s are games where players (that’s you!) play the roles of characters in a fictional setting and have all kinds of adventures. See where the stories take you!

Voice Box: We can have different opinions and still be friends and listen respectfully to each other. We're interested to learn about other people's points of view and we don't have to try to convince them to think like we do. This is where we share opinions about issues that are important to us.

Contests & Games: Do you love creating new contests or games for everyone to play? Do you love playing in them? This is the place for you to make your own contests and games and invite everyone to participate! Remember, just like everywhere else on NMGMembers.com, if you make a contest or game, it must be open to everyone who wants to join in!